Overcoming Empathy Fatigue in Patient Financial Services

Feb 12, 2020

How to create a positive patient experience when you just don’t feel like it.

The patient experience doesn’t end at the doctor’s office, the hospital, or the lab. In fact, patient financial services (PFS) teams are every bit as integral to the patient experience as a physical visit to a healthcare facility or medical treatment from a provider. And it’s the patient experience during the billing cycle that directly impacts healthcare organizations’ bottom lines.

Needless to say, PFS employees have a huge responsibility to patients (and the resulting success of their healthcare entities). But creating positive, empathetic patient experiences throughout the billing process is often easier said than done.

Check out our free, on-demand webinar to see how Disney can help you create an empathetic patient experience – every time. >>

“When team members hear patients say ‘My bill is too high’ over 40 times a day, empathy fatigue sets in. It gets easy to stop seeing patients as real people and truly caring about them,” says Diane Lawson, certified patient experience professional and Associate Director of Patient Financial Services at University of Colorado Medicine.

“Empathy is key to delivering an excellent patient experience,” says Lawson. “That’s why it’s so critical to help employees fight off feelings of discouragement and keep them connected to their purpose.”

So how can PFS teams combat empathy fatigue and show patients they care – even through all the questions, emotions, and heart-wrenching stories? It’s not easy. But empathy is a skill that can be learned, and the following “exercises” can help you and your revenue team repeatedly deliver truly excellent and empathetic patient experiences.

When team members hear patients say ‘My bill is too high’ over 40 times a day, empathy fatigue sets in. It gets easy to stop seeing patients as real people and truly caring about them.
Diane Lawson

Ass. Director of Patient Financial Services, University of Colorado Medicine

Encourage self-compassion

Any flight attendant or pilot will tell you to put on your own oxygen mask before assisting others. Why? Because you can’t help anyone else unless you’re taking in the air you need to stay strong.

The same concept applies when your team members are battling empathy fatigue. They need to take care of themselves – physically, mentally, and emotionally – so they are better prepared to take care of patients. Encourage employees to create “space” for themselves on a daily basis, multiple times a day. Show them the importance of physical space – listening to the body’s needs and getting away to decompress. Reinforce the need for mental space – maintaining personal perspective through mindfulness or meditation. And of course, encourage employees to show themselves compassion emotionally through positive internal dialogue.

Define the workplace attitude

Customer service expert Laurie McIntosh summarizes a healthy workplace attitude like this: “You are serving a customer, not a life sentence. Learn how to enjoy your work.”

Lawson reinforces these wise words and talks about how they translate to the patient experience. “At CU Medicine, we absolutely apply this sentiment to our interactions with patients,” she says. “Our purpose is to help patients. Revenue teams need reminded that we choose to do this job, and we are not stuck here.”

Post your organization’s purpose

Another way to ward off empathy fatigue among PFS team members is to continually connect employees with their purpose. “We post our purpose statement all over the department at CU Medicine,” says Lawson. “It’s a visual, everyday reminder of our ‘why.’”

By displaying your organization’s purpose where employees can regularly see it, you provide a regular reminder of the mission that unites your team.

Encourage an internal culture of empathy

Showing empathy to patients becomes easier when revenue teams first build a culture that celebrates and practices empathy. “There is no patient experience without employee engagement,” says Lawson. “And employees are much more likely to stay engaged when we all genuinely care for one another.”

Brené Brown once said that, “Empathy is infinite.” Lawson is continually brought back to that line. “When team members can support each other by sharing information, having potlucks, and celebrating milestones, they get the encouragement they need to pay it forward to patients,” she says.

Equip team members with talking points

Finally, talking points are essential in empowering employees to “make it right” with patients. (Check out the five rules of de-escalation here.)

“We all know that the healthcare industry is tightly regulated,” says Lawson. “We can’t always do what some other industries can to equip our employees for service reconciliation. What we can do is make sure that team members are as highly trained and skilled as possible.”

By providing employees with useful talking points (plus key phrases to avoid), PFS teams can ensure their team members are better prepared to demonstrate empathy rather than sympathy. This helps them serve patients, build trusted, vulnerable connections, and fulfill the organization’s purpose.

Webinar

“It was just one conversation. But that’s all it took."

In this free case study, see how empathy transformed a patient’s billing experience – and changed lives.

Karie Bostwick

VP of People and Compliance

As VP of People and Compliance at Revenue Enterprises, Karie Bostwick oversees People functions including recruiting, training, onboarding, engagement and satisfaction. Additionally, she is responsible for compliance training, oversight and monitoring.

Karie has a long history of working in the revenue cycle support industry. Her skills span leadership, operations start up, policies and procedures development, operations workflow, budgeting and client management.

She is passionate about the experience of our people, patients and the Healthcare clients we serve and believes that a team of diverse, talented and motivated individuals working together toward a common goal can make a difference.

Robert Sterett

VP of Information Technology

As a transformational leader Robert Sterrett has leveraged his 20 years of experience to build effective service lines and exceptional teams. In his role as VP of Information Technology at Revenue Enterprises, Robert excels at taking a unique, balanced, and strategic approach to technology leadership with people first for the best possible outcome. Using his experience from engineering, project management and service line management he takes a multi-faceted approach to ensure the right people are in the correct position coupled with the best technology to meet or exceed all expectations from security to compliance and business continuity.

Robert’s leadership style lends itself to building long term relationships and has consistently been a relied upon strength in many organizations. Over Robert’s time as an IT operational and project leader, he has spent significant time in both hands-on technology facing roles and client centric management roles to bring the best solutions that strive to meet the business and client needs.

Focusing heavily on his personal development skills and opportunities, Robert continues to foster coaching and mentorship relationships everywhere in his life, and the lives around him.

Douglas Dunbar

VP of Sales & Marketing

As VP of Sales and Marketing for Revenue Enterprises, Douglas Dunbar leads with a passion for building strategic partnerships, nurturing relationships, and upholding customer service excellence. In his role, Doug focuses on marketing and brand strategy, sales team leadership, and working closely with members of the management team to best serve company goals.

Doug has over 28 years of National sales and marketing call/contact center leadership, with 10 years of service specifically at Revenue Enterprises. Currently, Doug serves as part of Wyoming HFMA Chapter leadership and has held various roles in Colorado HFMA Chapter leadership for over 9 years.

In his spare time, Doug is very family oriented. Additionally, he loves traveling, cycling, golfing, fishing, hunting, and boating.

Kris Brumley, MBA

SVP/COO

As SVP/COO of Revenue Enterprises, Kris Brumley is a collaborative partner within the executive team and a leader for operational functions across the organization. Kris productively shares vision, drives innovation, and supports those around her in a way that elevates them and fosters continuous improvement and results. She has helped create a supportive environment for clients resulting in 98% client retention and a 65% NPS score for all clients and 75% for top clients by revenue.

Kris possesses an MBA in data analytics and has twenty-five years of experience in the healthcare industry, with 19 specifically in revenue cycle. She brings a wealth of customer service experience to her role and has worn many hats at Revenue Enterprises including Director of Business Development, EBO Division Director, and VP of Client Experience Management.

In her personal life, Kris is as busy outside of work as inside. She values spending time with her family, and enjoys fishing, hiking, traveling and interior decorating and design.

Timothy (Tim) Brainerd

CEO

As CEO of Revenue Enterprises for almost 20 years, Tim Brainerd leads by example. He promotes a shared vision and stewards a culture of Integrity, Passion, and Respect. He has assembled and empowered high-performing talent and teams to support customers, facilitate strategic planning and manage the capital of the company. Under his leadership, Revenue Enterprises has doubled in size three times over the past fifteen years while maintaining a culture of caring and gratefulness.

Tim has close to four decades of revenue cycle experience, including nineteen years with RSI
Enterprises. He has been a past president of Colorado Chapter of the HFMA and a presenting speaker on the topic of Leadership. He is a fifteen-year member of Vistage International, the world’s largest CEO coaching and peer advisory organization for small and midsize business leaders.

Raised in the Midwest, Tim values humble principles like being respectful, caring, passionate, self-reliant, and most importantly grateful. His most important lesson and the lesson he hopes to pass on in all relationships is living the Golden Rule–do unto others as you would have them do unto you. He is intentional in his choices and believes in making decisions, taking action, being accountable, and loving your neighbors.

Whenever possible, Tim spends his time with his wife of nearly forty years, his adult children, and his grandchildren. His hobbies include fishing, golfing, traveling as well as game nights and sharing great food with his family.